(800) 689-1273
Facebook Twitter Youtube Linkedin
Prospect Genius logo

Prospect Genius

Menu
Log In
You are here: Home / Blog

Can You Actually Rank in AI Search Without a Website?

Last Updated: December 2, 2025

AI search is changing how people find businesses online. Tools like Gemini, Grok, Copilot, and Perplexity don’t just show web links, they generate answers by pulling info from all over the internet, including social media, videos, and forums.

So the big question is:

Can your business show up in AI search results even if you don’t have a website?

Technically: yes.
Practically? It’s a very steep, expensive, and time-consuming climb.

Your Two Real Options

Here’s what this really comes down to:

Option 1: With a Website (The Classic Path)

  • Build a clean, fast website
  • Add keyword-optimized service pages
  • Set up your Google Business Profile
  • Get listed in a few high-authority directories
  • Add a bit of content and build backlinks
  • See steady growth in both AI and traditional search rankings

Time: Low to moderate
Cost: Affordable
Outsourcing: Easy
Control: You own everything

Option 2: Without a Website (The Content-Scatter Approach)

  • Optimize all your social media bios
  • Write helpful answers on Quora and Reddit
  • Publish on Medium or Substack weekly
  • Make YouTube or TikTok videos
  • Get mentioned in podcasts or blogs
  • Build out dozens of directory listings manually
  • Keep it all fresh and updated… forever

Time: High
Cost: Expensive
Outsourcing: Difficult and high-skill
Control: Scattered across other people’s platforms

First, Let’s Be Clear: AI Optimization = SEO Plus

There’s no shortcut. AI optimization isn’t some new miracle strategy, it’s just SEO, plus a few smart extras.

The foundation still matters:

  • A strong, well-structured website
  • Accurate service and contact information
  • Helpful content with real expertise
  • A complete Google Business Profile
  • Clean, consistent directory listings

AI search builds on top of this by looking for additional signals:

  • New content elements like FAQs and LLMs.txt files
  • Videos
  • Forum posts
  • Q&A content
  • Local mentions
  • Entity consistency across platforms

The good news? Some of these add-ons are still pretty easy to capitalize on, because most of your competitors haven’t caught on yet.

That’s why we created the AI Optimization QuickStart service. It’s affordable, it’s fast, and (for those of you with a website) it’s often all you need to start showing up in AI search… for now.

As things evolve and more businesses catch on, we also offer full AEO (Answer Engine Optimization) and GEO (Generative Engine Optimization) packages to keep you ahead.

First-mover advantage is real. The businesses that show up early in AI search tend to stay there. Be one of them.

What Does It Actually Take?

Option A: No Website – Full External Content Strategy

(interpret times and costs as ballpark estimates)

Task Time Required Outsourcing Cost
Social profile setup & optimization 5 – 10 hrs upfront $300 – $500 one-time
Weekly YouTube/TikTok content 4 – 8 hrs/week $500 – $1,500/month
Reddit/Quora answers 2 – 4 hrs/week $500 – $1,000/month
Substack or LinkedIn articles 2 – 3 hrs/week $400 – $800/month
Directory listings & maintenance 2 – 3 hrs/month $300 – $800 one-time

Estimated monthly cost: $1,500 – $3,500
Time (DIY): 10 – 20 hours per week
Estimated 1-year cost (low-end estimate): $17,400 or 520 hours of your time (2.5 hrs/day)
Result: You might get visibility if you’re consistent for months

Option B: Website + Local SEO (The Smart & Scalable Route)

(interpret times and costs as ballpark estimates)

Task Time Required Cost Estimate
Website (with built-in SEO + AI Optimization) 20 – 30 hrs (setup) $2,000 – $4,000 one-time
Google Business Profile + Directory Listings 2 – 4 hrs $200 – $300 one-time, then ~$100/month
Light ongoing content (blogs, social, minor updates) 2 – 3 hrs/month $100 – $300/month

Estimated total startup cost: $2,200 – $4,300
Estimated monthly upkeep: $100 – $300
Time (DIY): 4 – 6 hours/month

Estimated 1-year cost (mid-tier estimate): $6,850 and up to 85 hours of your time (1.6 hours/week for content approvals and report review)
Outsourcing difficulty: Low, this is easy to delegate
Long-term value: High, you own the results

 

So, going with the website saves you at least 435 hours of time, or about $10,000 in expense, over just ONE year.

 

A Quick Word About Wix, Squarespace, and Other Site-Builders

We get it, drag-and-drop site builders like Wix and Squarespace look like an easy win. We often say, “They make some hard things easy, but they make a lot of easy things hard.”

For example:

  • Want to add an LLMs.txt file for AI optimization? Normally, that’s minutes. In Squarespace, it’s a workaround involving redirects.
  • Want to fine-tune SEO metadata, schema, or structured data? You’re limited by templates.
  • Want to fully own your website? You can’t, you’re renting space on their platform.

These platforms lock you in. Over time, those limitations pile up. You’re stuck with rigid structures, clunky performance, and fewer options to keep up as AI and SEO rules change.

That’s why we don’t recommend them.

Instead, go with WordPress or other self-hosted platforms that give you:

  • Full control over content and code
  • Infinite customization
  • Better long-term performance
  • Freedom to adapt as your business grows

If you’re going to build the house, make sure you own the land, and can renovate it when needed.

Owning vs. Renting: Why a Website Is Still the Smart Move

Trying to grow your business without a website is like renting dozens of tiny rooms in other people’s buildings.

  • Some posts on Reddit
  • A few videos on YouTube
  • A random article on Medium
  • Profiles on Yelp and Google Maps

You’re spread out everywhere, but you don’t own any of it. And at any time, the platform can change the rules, block your content, or bury your listings.

Your website is your house. You control it. You customize it. You build value in it over time. It’s an asset, and if you work with a provider like us, you actually own it, not just rent it.

Even a simple website gives your business a central home base, and Google and AI search engines love that structure.

Final Verdict: Build the House

Can you rank in AI search without a website? Yes. But unless you’re a full-time content creator with a big budget and a lot of time, it’s not a winning strategy.

If you’re a local service business trying to get leads, bookings, or phone calls, a website isn’t optional, it’s essential, and AI has made it more-so not less.

Build your house. Own your space. Connect your Google Business Profile. Then, layer on extra content and AI optimization when you’re ready.

It’s faster, easier, and far more effective than trying to win the internet one rented room at a time.

Ready to Get Started?

Ask us about our AI Optimization QuickStart, a fast, affordable way to start building visibility in AI search right now.

Or, if you’re ready to go all in, check out our full AEO and GEO packages for next-level results.

Let’s build something you actually own, and that actually works.

Turns Out, That Lying Scoundrel Simply Answered the Question You Didn’t Know You Asked

Last Updated: November 17, 2025

Leer en español

This might sound strange, but here it goes: we’re about to stick up for some of our competitors.

Yes, really.

Now, don’t get us wrong, there are plenty of bad apples out there. Some are just plain incompetent. Others are full-on scammers. But believe it or not, there are some honest, well-meaning marketing folks out there who actually know what they’re doing. The problem? Even they can end up sounding like snake oil salesmen… and it’s not always their fault.

Let’s talk about why.

When Words Don’t Mean What You Think They Mean

One of the biggest issues in digital marketing today isn’t shady tactics or overpriced services, it’s language. Over the years, scammers and clueless marketers have tossed around industry buzzwords like candy at a parade. Terms get twisted, misused, or misunderstood until they mean something totally different to different people.

And that’s where things start to break down.

You think you’re asking a simple question. The marketing person thinks they’re giving a straight answer. But really, you’re both speaking different languages, and neither of you realizes it.

A Conversation That’s Not Really a Conversation

Here’s a common example:
You say, “I want to outrank [insert-evil-competitor-guy-here]. We need to beat him!”
That sounds clear enough, right?

But what you really mean is, “I want to compete effectively online, without spending a fortune.”
Meanwhile, the marketing person hears your question and thinks you’re asking how to dominate every corner of the internet, 24/7, which, spoiler alert, would take an unlimited budget. So they say, “You’ll need to spend a ton of money.”

Now you think they’re either clueless, lying, or just trying to get a fat payout from you. They think you asked a billion-dollar question. Nobody’s wrong, but nobody’s on the same page either.

Another one we hear all the time:
“I want to rank #1.”
Do you mean #1 in the local map pack? #1 in the regular organic listings? In paid ads? On mobile? Desktop? On Google? In ChatGPT? All of the above? Because to us, those are all very different things, and they require very different strategies. But to you, it just means, “I want people to find me first.”

It’s not your fault. Industry terms like “map pack,” “knowledge graph,” or “blended search results” don’t mean much to most people, and why would they? So folks make up their own terms that make sense in their heads. The problem is, sometimes those made-up terms already mean something else to the person you’re talking to.

The “Checkmark” Confusion

Here’s another one that gets people riled up:
“How do I get that little green checkmark next to my name on Google?”

Simple answer: that’s part of Google’s Local Services Ads program, which means you have to buy into their lead system. But when we tell a client that, they might think we’re just trying to sell them something extra. All they wanted was the checkmark. What they didn’t know is that the checkmark comes with the program, not separate from it.

Nobody’s lying. But again, it feels like we’re having two different conversations.

A Quick Story (and a Good Laugh)

One time, we had a client, let’s call him Bob, who kept saying his service needed to be “above the fold.” That’s a classic design term that means the content should be visible on the screen before someone starts scrolling. But Bob thought it just meant something should be prominent so people know it’s important. After we kept telling him that it simply wasn’t possible to have EVERYTHING above the fold, he replied with “I get that, of course, so just move it further down the page.” (In other words, below the fold.)

Cue confused faces.

Turns out, he totally misunderstood what “above the fold” meant. He’d just heard it somewhere, thought it simply meant “prominent,” and started using it. And hey, we get it! But it’s a perfect example of how quickly the wires can get crossed.

So What’s the Takeaway?

Even though it might feel a little strange to stick up for our competitors, here’s what we’re really asking:

Be as specific as possible when you make a marketing request. Try to leave the jargon out unless you’re absolutely sure you’re using it correctly. Instead, just describe what you want in plain language.

Why? Because when you use an industry term, especially one that sounds polished or technical, the person on the other end of the phone might think, “Ah, this person knows exactly what they’re asking for.” And they’ll take your question at face value, with no need for translation.

But if what you meant is different from what that term actually means, the conversation heads in the wrong direction before it even starts.

The clearer you are, the better we can help, and that goes for us, and yes, even for the good folks on our competitor’s teams.

ScamWatch: Don’t Pay for What’s Already Yours – The Google Business Profile Ownership Scam

Last Updated: November 10, 2025

Leer en español

We’ve been hearing a lot of chatter lately from our clients about a sneaky new scam making the rounds, and it’s time we shine a big ol’ spotlight on it.

Here’s the setup:
You, a small business owner, get a call. The person on the other end – often with an overseas accent – says they’re offering you “full ownership” of your Google Business Profile (GBP) for a one-time payment. Sometimes it’s $300, sometimes a little more or less. They’ll promise you sole ownership, the ability to delete any reviews you don’t like, and full control over your listing.

Sounds official, right? Maybe even a little tempting?

Don’t fall for it.

Let’s break down why this is 100% a scam and what you actually should know about your Google Business Profile.

1. Google Business Profiles are always free

You do not have to pay to claim, manage, or use your GBP. Google offers this service to business owners completely free of charge. Anyone asking for money in exchange for “ownership” is either confused or trying to rip you off.

2. You can’t “own” your GBP the way they say you can

The terminology these scammers use is misleading at best. While you can claim your GBP and become the primary owner (which gives you full control), that process involves verifying your business – not sending someone your credit card info.

Think of it like your social media account: you sign up, prove it’s yours, and manage it as you see fit. But it’s still hosted by a platform (Google) that has its own rules and systems.

3. “Sole owner” is a made-up title

This is where the scammers get clever. They’ll toss around the term “sole owner” like it’s some kind of premium status. In reality, a GBP has one primary owner, and that person can assign managers or additional owners if they want to. But that’s a management structure – not a tiered payment system. You either have control of your profile or you don’t.

4. You cannot delete reviews just because you don’t like them

This is one of the juiciest promises scammers dangle – “Give us a few hundred bucks and you can remove any bad reviews you want.” Not true. Google has clear policies about reviews, and the only way one gets removed is if it violates those policies. Owning or managing your GBP doesn’t change that.

So, what can you pay for?

It’s completely valid to hire someone to help you recover access to a lost profile, optimize your listing, or manage your local SEO. That’s like hiring a lawyer to handle paperwork or a plumber to fix your leak – you’re paying for expertise, not for something that’s supposed to be free.

But you should never pay someone just to “own” your GBP. That’s like someone selling you the title to your own house after you’ve already moved in.

Final thoughts

Scams like these rely on confusion, urgency, and a bit of fear. They target hardworking business owners who are too busy running their companies to double-check every call that comes in.

So let’s keep it simple:
If someone says you have to pay to own your Google Business Profile, hang up.
If you’re ever unsure about a call or email like this, reach out to someone you trust – your marketing team, your web agency, or even a savvy friend.

We’ll be back with more ScamWatch tips soon. Until then, stay sharp out there.

The Geeks At Google Just Threw A Monkey Wrench Into Your Day

Last Updated: November 4, 2025

Leer en español

Up in their ivory tower, Google’s just cooked up what they seem to think are a pair of small changes. But out here in the real world, we’re about to face a mess. They just turned Google Maps into HomeAdvisor AND are giving you less value for your Local Service Ads (LSA) dollar.

Let’s rip the Band-Aid off, then go over some ways you can salvage a win from each of these changes.

1. The “Have AI Get Prices” Button

Google just turned your business into a line item on a price comparison list with this new feature they’re trialing. It’s appearing in some areas and for some searches, but there’s a high probability this becomes a standard feature soon.

What it looks like

A new blue button now appears under the map-pack: “Have AI Get Prices.”

Google's new "have AI get prices" button on google map results

How this likely works

  1. Customer taps
  2. Google’s bot calls or texts you and your competitors looking for pricing info
  3. You have just moments to blindly name a price or be left out
  4. Google compiles the data and delivers it via text or email to the customer

What we expect it to look like from the business’ side

Let’s say someone searches for “shower repair in Austin.” Instead of calling you, they tap the button.

  1. Google’s AI sends your business a message (via call, text, or chat) asking for a price quote based on the user’s request.
  2. You’ll get a short message like: “A customer in your area is looking for a price to repair a leaking shower. Please reply with an estimate.”
  3. You won’t know much. Most likely you’ll have no photos, no call, no way to ask questions. Just a vague request and a tight window to answer.

It’s starting to sound a lot like HomeAdvisor, but with even less interaction with the client. It’s turning you into a commodity.

Why it feels like a gut punch

  • You’re in the middle of a job.
  • You have no idea what the problem ACTUALLY looks like.
  • If you ghost the bot, it instantly serves the job to the two other guys who answered in 11 seconds.

It’s HomeAdvisor-style race-to-the-bottom

Week 1: Everyone quotes real prices.
Week 2: The clown low-balling by $200 wins every lead.
Week 3: Margins are gone and you hate your life.
Week 4: The clown is broke and so are you.

How to win anyway (do this now)

  1. Build a response plan
    Prepare some fast, flexible “starting at” responses that give customers something to compare, without locking you into a price. These can be saved as quick replies or text snippets on your phone.
Snippet 1: “Typical shower rebuild starts at $398. Requires a free 15-min inspection to confirm.”
Snippet 2: “Drippy faucet fixes usually run $109 and up. Same-day available.”
Snippet 3: “Water heater replacement starts at $1,299. Includes haul-away of old heater.”
  1. Make sure someone answers the AI
    You need someone who can respond fast. That can be your office admin, your cousin who’s helping part-time, or a dedicated answering service. Give them your pricing sheet and let them reply to AI quote requests instantly while you’re on the job. It’s actually more affordable than most people think.
    We recommend Professional Answering Service. We’ve worked with them before and can get you preferential rates if you want to give them a shot.
  2. Close the upsell in the driveway
    These quotes are just your foot in the door. The real money comes when you’re face-to-face with the homeowner. When presented with a Goldilocks style list of options, a large percentage will choose the better, more-profitable option. That’s your paycheck, so don’t leave it on the table.

Set this up by Friday and the bot becomes your $0 receptionist.

2. Green “Guaranteed” Badge Is Now A Blue “Verified” Badge

Google killed the green checkmark and the $2,000 refund promise in October. No longer do you get the guarantee that came with your LSA campaign.

What you still have

    • Same top-of-page LSA placement.
    • Same background checks.
  • Nearly the same trust, but now in millennial blue.

How to Turn This Into a Win

  1. Screenshot your new blue badge.
  2. Text your recent customers:

“Hey John! We just went Google Verified 🔥 Quick 20-second favor: tap here to leave us a review?”
[Link straight to your Google review form]

  1. Add one line to every email, invoice, and homepage:
    “Google Verified + OUR Fix-It-Free Promise”

Here’s the truth:

  • These tools are built for customers, not for your convenience.
  • Ignoring them doesn’t make THEM go away…just YOU.
  • Playing along (smartly) can still put money in your pocket.

So prep your price snippets. Get someone on quote duty. Show off that shiny blue badge. You don’t have to be the cheapest, you just have to be the fastest to show up and the best at following through.

Do that, and the robot doesn’t replace you, it routes the job straight to you.

 

 

Google Changes & Local Service Business FAQs


Google is trialing a new feature where a “Have AI Get Prices” button appears in the local map results. When a user taps it, Google’s bot may contact your business and competitors via call, text or chat to get price quotes, then the user receives a compiled list of prices. This turns your service into a commodity‑list item.


Because the business gets very little context — no photos, limited information, and only a short time window to respond. This “quote‑race” dynamic can force businesses into low‑margin bidding, resembling the model of lead‑generation platforms like HomeAdvisor.


Prospect Genius recommends: (1) Build “starting at” pricing snippets you can respond with quickly; (2) Ensure someone (an answering service or staff) is ready to respond instantly to the AI quote request; (3) Use the quick quote to get the prospect in the door, then upsell the profit‑making job when you meet the customer in person.


Google replaced the green “Guaranteed” badge (which included a refund promise) with a blue “Verified” badge in October. This means the refund guarantee is gone, though the placement and background check requirements remain largely unchanged.


Businesses should screenshot the blue badge, promote it by text‑messaging recent customers to leave reviews, and add a line on their website/emails/invoices like “Google Verified + OUR Fix‑It‑Free Promise” to maintain trust and differentiate despite the removed refund guarantee.


The broader message is: these tools are built for consumers, not necessarily optimized for your convenience. Ignoring the changes doesn’t make them go away—but adapting can allow you to harness them. Be the fastest to respond and deliver the best experience, so rather than being replaced by the bot, you become the routed business.

Sign up for our newsletter!

Join our mailing list and receive regular updates on how to effectively market your small business, along with exclusive service promotions.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.