• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
(800) 689-1273
Facebook Twitter Youtube Linkedin
Prospect Genius logo

Prospect Genius

Menu
  • Services
    • Websites
      • CoreSite
      • Free Google Business Profile Website Alternative
    • SEO
      • CleanSlate
      • Directory Dominator
      • SEO Content Writing Services
    • A.I.
      • AI Optimization Quick Start
      • GEO – Generative Engine Optimization
      • AEO – Answer Engine Optimization
    • Social Media
      • SocialStart
      • SocialBuzz
      • SocialStream
    • Pay Per Click
      • Google Adwords
      • Facebook / Instagram Ads
      • Remarketing
    • Email Marketing
      • EmailStream
      • ReviewStream
    • Tools
      • PhoneSwap
      • CallTrax
      • Spaminator
      • EmailMask
      • WebFax
      • AdTrax
      • MapTrax
    • Google Business Profile
      • Google Business Profile Rescue
      • Google Review Rescue
      • Google Business Profile Optimization
      • Google Review StarSaver
  • Reviews
  • FAQ
  • About Us
    • Blog
    • Charity
  • Contact Us
Log In
You are here: Home / Blog / 12 Reasons Using Multiple SEO Companies Is a Terrible Idea

12 Reasons Using Multiple SEO Companies Is a Terrible Idea

Last Updated: February 15, 2024

You’ve heard the saying, “Two heads are better than one.” You’ve probably heard it too many times to count. It’s so ingrained in our minds, in fact, that we apply it to virtually every situation we find ourselves in.
However, there are many scenarios in which two heads are NOT better than one. Online advertising is one of them.
If you’re working with one SEO company and decide to hire another one, you won’t be doubling your chances at success. You won’t promote your business twice as fast. You won’t get twice the number of leads.
All that happens is you waste your money and destroy the performance of your campaign. Truly, using multiple SEO companies is a terrible idea. Here’s why.

1. You’re paying for overlapping services.

that don't make no sense
Why pay for services from multiple companies that are all doing the same thing?

2. You’re paying twice the cost for half the result. 

burning money
Working with more than one SEO company at a time will weaken your online presence. So not only are you paying double what you need to, but you’re also getting very little out of it.

3. You’ll draw suspicion from Google.

suspicious
With multiple companies working on your advertising, your listings will be updated very frequently. This looks fishy to Google. Nothing good happens when Google is suspicious of you.

4. You could be penalized by Google.

penalty flag
Google will likely view your listing as spam if there are frequent updates from several different locations. And, as you know by now, Google takes spam very seriously. This could lead to your business plummeting in rankings or even getting suspended entirely.

5. You could end up with multiple Google listings. 

Billie-Joe-Armstrong-WTF
With more than one company advertising for you, there’s a risk that one of them will create a new Google listing for you, even if you already have one. This may sound like a win, but it’s not. Unfortunately, “The more the merrier!” does not apply to Google listings. In fact, Google is highly suspicious of businesses with multiple listings. This could lead to suspended listings and lost customer reviews.

6. You’ll confuse the people who find you online.

confused little girl
If you do wind up with multiple listings that contain different information, then your customers will probably get confused. They may not be able to tell which listing is the real you. Instead of calling you, this uncertainty will just cause them to move on to the next company they find.

7. Constant battling means no one’s in control. 

fighting for control
Since your SEO companies will be battling each other for control, there’s no prevailing strategy for your online advertising. With no clear route mapped out, where is your campaign going? And how is it going to get there?

8. Your SEO companies undo each other’s work.

working against each other
It’s impossible to get fast results when your SEO companies keep undoing each other’s work (whether they realize it or not). When players on the same team work against each other, winning is pretty much out of the question.

9. Fighting makes your advertisers grumpy. 

Steve-Carell-Facepalm
Who wants to fight tooth-and-nail just so they can do their job?

10. In fact, NO ONE is happy.

angry mob
It frustrates Google because you look like a spammer. It frustrates your SEO companies because they’re trying to do their jobs with one hand tied behind their backs. And it frustrates you because you’re getting poor results.

11. Your rankings drop. 

plummeting
Whether it’s because Google penalizes you or there’s a bevy of conflicting information floating around, working with more than one SEO company will cause your rankings to plummet.

12. It’s one GIANT headache. 

headache
Even if you ignore all the above facts or you somehow avoid any negative consequences (e.g. dropped rankings, suspensions, and penalties), it’s still a massive pain for all parties involved. Life is a lot easier when you work with just one SEO company at a time. 
Even though we’ve covered this topic with funny gifs, it’s a serious issue. Using multiple SEO companies can drain your bank account and tank your web presence. Please heed our advice and think twice before doubling up.
Prospect Genius logo

Contact Us

Prospect Genius
279 Troy Rd
Ste 9 #102
Rensselaer, NY 12144

Business Hours

Mon – Fri: 9am – 6pm ET

 (800) 689-1273
 hello@prospectgenius.com

Let’s Connect!

Facebook Twitter Youtube Linkedin

What Drives Us?

Our passion is helping small businesses thrive. It’s why we get out of bed every day. Too many business owners are cheated and lied to every day so we see it as our duty to be a beacon of truth, a safe harbor, in an often unscrupulous industry.

Client Portal App


Helpful Links

  • Case Studies
    • Negative Review Attack
    • Resiliency of SEO Strategies
    • Facebook Ads for Growth
    • Google PPC Ads Double Calls
    • Facebook Ads vs Google Ads
    • SEO Brings Online Success
    • GBP Optimization
    • Prospect Genius > Home Advisor
    • CleanSlate Creates NAP Win
  • Professional Answering Services
  • Integrity Pledge
  • Porting a CallTrax Phone Number
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • About
  • FAQ
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

Sign up for our newsletter!

Join our mailing list and receive regular updates on how to effectively market your small business, along with exclusive service promotions.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Suspended Map Listing?

Just 2 failed attempts at reinstatement and your listing is gone forever! Luckily, we have a nearly 100% success rate!!

Google Business Profile Rescue

Don't Waste Your PPC Budget

PPC ads will quickly drain your budget if you don’t optimize them well.

Learn About Our PPC Services